Your success is at the forefront of our minds.

Business Interruption Insurance in South Africa: What It Pays When You Cannot Trade

Home / Blog / Business Interruption Insurance

TL;DR: Business interruption (BI) insurance replaces the profit you lose and pays the extra costs of keeping going after an insured event stops you from trading. In South Africa it is usually tied to a valid property damage claim, it is calculated on “insurance gross profit” rather than your accounting gross profit, and it only pays for as long as your chosen indemnity period. Getting those three things right matters more than the headline sum insured. Cover for power failure, closures without physical damage and supplier problems is narrower than many businesses assume.

Picture a fire that is put out in an hour. The building is repaired in four months. Winning back the customers who went elsewhere while the doors were closed takes a year and a half. That is why property damage is often the smaller part of a serious loss. The larger part is the income that stops while rent, salaries and loan repayments carry on.

Business interruption insurance is the cover designed for that gap. This guide explains how it works in South Africa, how the sum insured and indemnity period should be set, what the courts said about it during COVID-19, and where cover is now narrower than it used to be. It is general information. The wording of your own policy will decide how a claim is paid.

Business premises with roller shutters closed, the kind of enforced closure business interruption insurance responds to

In this article

What is business interruption insurance?

Business interruption insurance, sometimes called consequential loss cover, is a section of a commercial insurance programme that pays for the financial effect of an insured event rather than the physical damage itself. Where a fire, flood or other insured peril damages your premises, the property section pays to repair or replace the building, plant and stock. The BI section pays for the profit you lose while turnover is down, and for reasonable extra costs you incur to keep trading.

It is normally arranged alongside commercial property insurance, and for larger or more complex sites as part of a commercial and industrial risk programme.

Most South African BI cover only responds when there is a valid claim under the property damage section of the same policy, and the damage must happen while the policy is in force. This requirement is often called the material damage proviso. Extensions to BI cover are usually worded the same way, so that the loss must follow “in consequence of” insured damage.

In practice this means two things. First, if the property damage is not covered, for example because of an exclusion, the BI claim usually fails too. Second, a closure with no physical damage, such as an access road closed by authorities, is generally only covered if the policy has a specific extension for it.

What a BI policy pays

A standard gross profit BI policy typically pays:

  • Loss of gross profit: the insured gross profit rate applied to the drop in turnover during the indemnity period, compared with what turnover would have been.
  • Increased cost of working: reasonable extra spending to avoid or reduce the drop in turnover, such as temporary premises, hired equipment, overtime or extra advertising. Santam gives the example of paying rent and advertising costs for temporary premises after a loss.
  • Additional items, depending on the wording, such as wages on a separate basis, auditors’ fees to prepare the claim, and specified extensions.

Other bases exist, including revenue, net profit and standing charges, and some businesses insure rent receivable or fees separately. The right basis depends on how your business earns money.

Insurance gross profit is not your accounting gross profit

The most common BI mistake is setting the sum insured from the gross profit line in the annual financial statements. Insurance gross profit is defined differently. Typically, only variable costs such as purchases, bad debts and discounts are deducted from turnover, because most other costs continue while the business is closed.

Santam’s guidance to brokers makes three further points worth applying:

  • The gross profit sum insured should include VAT.
  • It should cover 12 months of gross profit, or the matching multiple where the indemnity period is longer than 12 months. An 18-month indemnity period needs 18 months of gross profit insured.
  • It should allow for growth, because a claim is measured against what turnover would have been, not what it was last year.

If the sum insured is too low, the insurer may apply average, which reduces the claim in proportion to the shortfall. Underinsurance is one of the reasons BI claims pay less than businesses expect. Our guide to commercial property insurance for business owners covers valuation discipline in more detail.

Choosing the indemnity period

The indemnity period is the maximum time after the damage for which the policy pays your loss. It is not the time until you reopen. It needs to cover rebuilding or repairing the premises, sourcing and commissioning replacement plant, and the time it takes for turnover to recover once you are trading again.

Imported machinery, specialist fit-outs, municipal approvals and customers who sign contracts with a competitor in the meantime can all stretch recovery well beyond the repair date. For many businesses, 12 months is too short. The cost of a longer period is usually modest compared with the risk of cover running out while the business is still recovering.

What the COVID-19 cases changed

South Africa’s courts dealt with BI in detail during the pandemic, and two Supreme Court of Appeal decisions still shape how the cover is understood.

  • Guardrisk Insurance Company Ltd v Café Chameleon CC [2020] ZASCA 173. The policy covered interruption due to a notifiable disease occurring within 50 km of the premises. The SCA unanimously held that the loss was caused by both the local outbreak and the government’s lockdown response, and that the policy covered both. The FSCA said the judgment provided legal certainty and expected insurers to pay valid claims without delay.
  • Santam Ltd v Ma-Afrika Hotels (Pty) Ltd [2021] ZASCA 141. Santam argued that its infectious disease extension paid for only three months. The SCA held that the indemnity period for loss of revenue was 18 months, as the policy schedule stated, and dismissed the appeal.

Santam reported that contingent BI claims accounted for R3.2 billion of its record R24.5 billion in gross claims for 2021, including R1 billion of relief paid in August 2020.

The market’s response was to narrow cover. In April 2022, for example, Old Mutual Insure told brokers it would no longer provide BI cover for interruption without physical damage, such as closure by authorities, and that its public utilities and telecommunications extensions would be limited to insured perils from August 2022 renewals. Some smaller non-damage extensions, such as food poisoning, vermin and bomb scares, were kept with a cap. Other insurers made similar changes, so it is worth checking exactly which non-damage events your policy still covers.

Load-shedding and grid failure

Many business owners assume that if the power goes off and they cannot trade, their BI cover will respond. In most cases it will not. Insurers have treated scheduled load-shedding as a known and predictable event rather than an insurable accident, and from 2023 some insurers went further.

Santam introduced a commercial exclusion for electricity grid failure or interruption, applying across the policy including consequential loss, for new business quoted from 1 January 2023 and renewals from 1 April 2023. It also capped public utilities BI cover at the lower of 50% of the BI limit or R25 million (VAT inclusive), with a three-month indemnity period, citing pressure from reinsurers.

The practical response is resilience rather than insurance: backup power, and cover for the backup equipment itself. If you have installed solar or batteries, see our guide to whether business insurance covers solar panels.

Riots, strikes and Sasria

Ordinary commercial policies exclude damage caused by riots, strikes, civil commotion, public disorder and terrorism. In South Africa that cover is provided by Sasria, and Sasria also offers business interruption cover on several bases, including gross profit, revenue and standing charges.

The scale of the risk became clear after the July 2021 unrest in KwaZulu-Natal and Gauteng. By July 2023 Sasria had paid more than R32 billion and settled 97% of around 17,500 claims. If your BI programme does not include Sasria BI, a riot that damages your premises can leave the property repaired and the lost profit uninsured. Our guide to what Sasria covers explains the cover in full, and where Sasria limits are not enough, political risk and political violence insurance can sit alongside it.

Extensions worth checking

Extensions widen BI cover beyond damage at your own premises. Names and limits vary by insurer, so read the schedule rather than assuming. The ones most worth reviewing are:

  • Suppliers and customers: loss caused by damage at a key supplier’s or customer’s premises. Useful where one supplier or buyer dominates your business. If the concern is a customer not paying rather than being damaged, that is a trade credit insurance question instead.
  • Prevention of access: loss when damage near your premises stops customers or staff getting in, even though your own property is undamaged.
  • Public utilities: loss from damage to supply infrastructure. Expect sub-limits, short indemnity periods and grid failure exclusions.
  • Goods in transit and stock elsewhere: where damage to stock away from your premises would stop you trading. Our guide to goods in transit insurance and to stock throughput cover explain how that stock can be insured.

A practical checklist

  • Recalculate insurance gross profit from your latest management accounts, with VAT and expected growth included.
  • Match the sum insured to the indemnity period: 18 months of gross profit for an 18-month period.
  • Test the indemnity period against a realistic worst case, including lead times for plant and approvals.
  • List which non-damage events are still covered, and their limits.
  • Confirm Sasria BI is in place alongside Sasria property cover.
  • Check supplier, customer and utility extensions against how your business actually depends on others.
  • Keep monthly turnover records accessible, because they are the basis of any claim.

If you would like your BI cover reviewed against how your business really trades, contact Berkley Risk or submit details through our online applications page. In Gauteng, see our Johannesburg and Sandton commercial property pages.

Frequently asked questions

What does business interruption insurance cover in South Africa?

It covers the gross profit a business loses while turnover is reduced after insured damage, plus reasonable extra costs incurred to keep trading, for up to the indemnity period chosen. Most South African BI cover requires a valid claim under the property damage section of the same policy.

Does business interruption insurance cover load-shedding?

Generally not. Scheduled load-shedding is treated as a predictable event, and since 2023 some insurers, including Santam, have applied exclusions for electricity grid failure or interruption. Public utilities extensions, where available, carry sub-limits and short indemnity periods.

What is a good indemnity period for business interruption cover?

It should cover the time to repair or rebuild, replace plant, and recover lost customers, not only the time until you reopen. Many businesses need more than 12 months, and the sum insured must be increased to match a longer period.

Is business interruption covered after a riot?

Not by an ordinary commercial policy, which excludes riot and strike damage. Sasria provides riot, strike and civil commotion cover in South Africa, including business interruption, and it needs to be added to your programme.

Why was my business interruption claim reduced?

Common reasons are a gross profit sum insured that was too low, leading to average being applied; an indemnity period that ended before turnover recovered; or a cause of loss, such as power failure or a closure without damage, that the policy does not cover.

Sources

Related reading